While debates and discussions have been ongoing about BBC Charter Review, the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) have published another Green Paper that has arguably even greater consequences for the UK’s media ecosystem.
‘Watch this Space: a new strategic direction for UK media’, published in June 2026, was widely expected to set out the government’s position on the future of digital terrestrial television (DTT). The DCMS have been looking into this area for a couple of years, including commissioning an independent report which I co-authored, and setting up a cross-sector Stakeholder Forum that concluded in 2025.
The challenge is that although 14% of UK households only used DTT (TV broadcast to an aerial in or on the home) in 2024, more and more people are watching television via the internet (IPTV) – a number that the DCMS expects to increase to 95% of UK households by 2034. Meanwhile, broadcasters are paying for distribution on DTT and via IPTV at a time when public and commercial revenues are declining and cuts are being made. And there are expectations that some of the UHF spectrum that DTT relies on will need to be released in the 2030s to improve mobile speeds and coverage. Doing so would require upgrading DTT to increase capacity in the network and maintain a sufficient number of television channels.
The decision about DTT switch-off is a difficult one. There is no stand-still option, and no easy solution, particularly at a time when the Government has little money to play with. Watch this Space proposes two dates for switch off: 2034 or 2044.
Switching off DTT in 2034 is the option preferred by the industry but would require a significant transition programme to ensure those dependent on DTT – more likely to be older, lower income, disabled and female – are not left behind. This requires addressing affordability, skills, usability, reliability and awareness. Affordability is a particular challenge, given that switching to IPTV adds ongoing broadband costs for households to be able to watch television. This is not a problem that can simply be solved by giving one-off financial support to those currently unable to afford broadband. And existing social tariffs are not cheap enough for the households most at risk. An ongoing ‘broadband safety net’ payment, along the lines of winter fuel payments, could address this. But this requires ongoing financial commitment from government at a time when ‘fiscal discipline’ appears to be driving policy decisions.
Switching off DTT in 2044 is also not without risk. It is expected that fewer households will need support from a transition programme because more will have organically adopted IPTV. However, some households will need to upgrade their TV sets to continue watching broadcast television when the DTT network is upgraded in the mid-2030s. There are also concerns that the channel offer from broadcasters is likely to be reduced. As audiences move away from DTT it will become commercially unviable for advertiser-funded broadcasters, creating a two-tier system where those that can afford IPTV have access to a far wider range of television than those dependent on DTT. Finally, the standards and governance for IPTV are likely to be set over the coming years, and a later switch-off date provides less incentive for the government to make IPTV operate in the public interest, including guarantees for accessibility, interoperability and reliability.
Beyond the expected proposals around DTT switch-off, Watch this Space also sets out new proposals to extend prominence – the legislation by which public service media (PSM) get increased visibility. Historically, prominence legislation gave PSM the top slots in the electronic programme guide. More recently, the 2024 Media Act extended prominence for PSM apps and programmes to smart TVs and connected devices, although this legislation has yet to be implements. Watch this Space proposes extending prominence in two further ways.
First, it suggests requiring social media to make ‘trustworthy news’ prominent and easily discoverable. Here the definition of a ‘trustworthy news provider’ is crucial. The Green Paper proposes adopting the Online Safety Act’s definition of a ‘recognised news provider’. This is an incredibly low bar that would place independently regulated PSM, like the BBC, on a par with self-regulated newspapers, such as the major national tabloids. This is particularly troubling because the Press Recognition Panel has raised multiple concerns about the efficacy of IPSO, the self-regulatory body for the majority of the UK’s larger national newspapers. Such an approach would also undermine the PSM compact[i] by which PSM are rewarded with prominence for the additional duties that they are required to undertake.
Second, it proposes extending PSM prominence to third-party platforms, including video-sharing platforms (VSPs) such as YouTube. These proposals are driven by changing viewing behaviours where, across all devices, viewers are spending an average of 51 minutes per day on VSPs, compared to just 25 minutes on broadcast on-demand services, like iPlayer. As the Green Paper states: ‘If PSM content is not visible on the platforms where key audiences spend their time, the government is concerned that the principle of universal access is not being achieved, and that this is fundamentally threatening the future of PSM content.’ However, Watch this Space makes relatively few concrete proposals in this space, preferring ‘voluntary agreements’ between PSM and platforms. To date, Channel 4, ITV and the BBC have all entered deals with YouTube, but these do not typically provide assurances that PSM content will be made prominent. And prominence alone will not address all the challenges facing PSM when distributing on VSPs. Reduced access to data, poor revenue-sharing arrangements and a fundamental lack of accountability are all significant challenges for PSM. We risk making our PSM system dependent on platforms that are operationalised for engagement without putting in place appropriate legislation to protect the public interest goals of PSM.[ii]
Right at the end of the Green Paper, however, the consequence of the platform ecosystem on PSM regulation becomes fully apparent. Watch this Space ends by exploring the systemic reforms that might be needed to enable PSM to meet the future challenges of the platform age. It proposes three, not mutually exclusive, models:
- PSM as institutions – such as broadcasters or streamers. This mirrors the UK’s current PSM system and the one widely adopted internationally.
- PSM as services – such as TV channels, VoD services, or channels on VSPs.
- PSM as content – such as certain types of programmes of genres, regardless of who provides them.
In some ways these proposals are not new. Defining PSM as content goes back at least as far as Ofcom’s proposals for a ‘public service publisher’ in 2004 when the UK was preparing for analogue switch off. However, our current media ecosystem, in which content is increasingly disaggregated, and in which PSM can no longer rely on their own services to reach audiences, gives these arguments increased purchase.
I can see the attraction of option 3. A robust definition of public service media content could open the doors for all sorts of online content creators and influencers who produce content that operates in the public interest to be supported as PSM. Yet Ofcom dropped the public service publisher idea for a reason – ultimately PSM is not about content, it is about systems. Defining PSM as content will not solve the problems facing PSM today. PSM has always been a systemic intervention in media markets. One that recognises that media left entirely in the hands of commercial or state operators will not serve the public interest. Once again, these proposals look in the wrong direction. The solution to the challenges facing our media system is not to redefine PSM, but rather to address the structural factors in our platformised media ecosystem that undermine the ability for PSM to operate in the public interest.
For me, this is where the different components of the Green Paper come together. Because regardless of the date selected for DTT transition, the vast majority of the UK will be watching TV within an IPTV ecosystem over the coming decade. We need that system to operate in the public interest and that requires policymakers not only look at how to transition those households that are dependent on DTT, but also how to create an IPTV ecosystem that operates for the public, is transparent, accountable, competitive and appropriately regulated.
The government’s response to its consultation on Watch the Space is expected to be published around the same time as its White Paper on BBC Charter Review, towards the end of 2026. All we can do for now is watch this space…
______________________________________________________________________________________________
Catherine Johnson is Professor of Media and Communication at the School of Media and Communication at the University of Leeds, where she also acts as Director of Impact. Her research has informed industry and policy, including at the Department for Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS), BBC, Channel 4, YouTube, Red Bee Media and Ofcom. She is a member of the DCMS College of Experts and has advised the DCMS Select Committee on the future of public service media and on their scrutiny of the Media Bill. Catherine currently leads the Public Service Media in the Age of Platforms project (PSM-AP), funded by a €1.5m CHANSE grant, that examines the impact of global streaming platforms on public service media in six countries.
Footnotes
[i] This is the technical term: it’s the regulatory deal between PSM and the government.
[ii] There is a risk as well that the platforms might benefit financially and reputationally from the collaboration with PSM which would not, at the same time, benefit the PSMs. In addition, it might reduce the need for the regulation of the platforms as well.